LLyn De Danaan riffs on the local music scene (Draft: Comments, Additions, Corrections Welcome. Always new music happening; always new history being uncovered.)
The Olympia Phenomenon
LLyn De Danaan riffs on the local music scene
A vibrant nurturing music community has developed over the past four or five decades in Olympia, Washington. Nonprofessionals, that is, people who simply love to play and listen to music with others, have a feast spread before them in this town of fewer than 50,000. That’s counting the people, i.e. the humans. But countless other species come out to party on the streets during the annual Procession of the Species.
If you like music, either as consumer or producer, Olympia, Washington has something for you nearly every night. There are: Sessions including Bay Shanty Sing and the Columbia Street Seisiun (which moved from its Columbia Street venue to Tugboat Annie’s and now is a largely private gathering according to the sesium web notes). There is the Quebecois Session, hosted by various members around town. There are jams such as Black Hills Pickin’ Party (which has a slow jam time to accommodate less seasoned musicians) and there are more or less private get togethers such as First Fridays.
Traditions Fair Trade, a café and fair trade outlet, has been open for around 17 years in its current location, according to Dick Meyers, the proprietor and gallant and charming host to many musicians over the years. The regular, busy calendar of musical events in Olympia, Dick says, “were a continuation of the concerts I did at the Antique Sandwich shop” in Tacoma. So counting both places, Dick has been sponsoring music events for about 37 years. Many groups have done well in these venues, including “Dirk Powell, Rani Arbo and Daisy Mahem, and Blackberry Bushes with the Water Tower Bucket Boys for instance.” There are, Dick says, about 65 concerts in a season. The attendance averages about “65-75 per show” with many sell-outs to appreciative standing room only audiences. Traditions is by far Olympia’s favorite hang out for progressives. Traditions also provides space for shape note singing sessions as well as blue grass and acoustic music jams.
That’s just a sampling of Olympia’s weekly and monthly music offerings. In addition there are regular “festivals” and street events such as twice yearly Art Walk and springtime Procession of the Species during which live music can be enjoyed on every corner.
There is an annual Old Time Music festival (coming up in February 15-17) as well as the once a year Blue Grass from the Forest and Fiddle Fest in nearby Shelton. The tally of available live and or participatory roots style music goes up if one counts the many appearances of musicians at the Farmer’s Market or in private pubs or house concerts. Alice Stuart (more about her later) does fabulous acoustic house concerts, Olympia Acoustic Music sponsors occasional shows, and the Buren Boys plays frequently at Cascadia Grill. This doesn’t begin to cover the musicians who play for the contra dance crowd that gathers at South Bay Grange on the first, second and fourth Saturdays of each month.
Indeed, most any dark and rainy winter nights you can throw on a slicker, a pair of Wellies, grab your guitar or fiddle and find somebody, somewhere with whom to play. Or leave the guitar at home and just go listen.
You can be the kid in the candy shop, as I most often am, simply enjoying not only the music but the communities, sometimes if not often overlapping, that come together to appreciate and play sing or listen to each other in homes and pubs, on street corners, or during festivals and community wide parties.
The Olympia Phenomenon
The story of music in Olympia most assuredly goes back before I moved to the area and began paying attention in 1971.
Olympia has a history not just of supporting roots music but also of being a Mecca for jazz artists, a petri dish for punk and garage, and a rich soil for the growth of Latin influenced bands. Before 1970s, there were notables like the Fleetwoods whose “Come Softly To Me” hit the top of the charts in the late 1950s. The Fleetwoods were the first group ever to have multiple hits in the Billboard top 100. The unsinkable, unstoppable Gretchen Christopher, a member of the trio and writer or co-writer of many of it songs, does solo work still and released an album in 2007. Coming to the fore, a bit after the Fleetwoods, a current Olympia, Port Commissioner, George Barner (one year behind Gretchen Christopher in Olympia High School), known as “Big George”, was a well-known rocker with Trendsetters. (His sister was the well-known Gracie Hansen who ran a Las Vegas Burlesque at Seattle Century 21 Exposition in 1962 called the Paradise Club. Later she fronted a show in Portland then ran for mayor and Governor of Oregon. I saw her review in the late 1960s when she hosted at the celebrated “Gay Nineties” themed Barbary Coast Lounge in Portland’s Hoyt Hotel. By the time I met George in 1972, his voice was already as raspy as a bear’s growl from years of hollering the lyrics to Louie Louie. (It was Washington State’s favorite and became, because of a 1985 campaign drive in 1985, almost became the STATE song.) Thousands of people came to Olympia for April 12, 1985 Louie Louie Day (declared by the Washington State Senate) to hear the Wailers, the Kingsmen, and Paul Revere and the Raiders rock the state capitol grounds.
Around about 1959, Don Rich (1941-1974), born Donald Eugene Ulrich in Olympia, was playing his fiddle and guitar in local venues. (Known as Don Ulrich then, he was in Barner’s class at Olympia High School.) Still a youngster, he was part of a band called the Blue Comets. That band, working in a South Tacoma restaurant, was observed by Buck Owens. Don was recruited. Don stayed with Buck Owens until his own, tragic death in a motorcycle accident in 1974. Together they made country music history and recorded hit after hit. A recording that shows off his fiddle playing is Tumwater Breakdown, named for the town, still considered a suburb of Olympia then, in which he grew up. You can listen to a clip at:
Tumwater Breakdown is on Don’s posthumous anthology album called Country Pickin’.
For memories of Don by his Olympia High School friend, see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aXIEjdCLV4
By the 1970s, a spectacular local jazz scene was treating Olympia audiences to top of the heap music. Bassist Red Kelley, who had toured with Woody Herman and played with Harry James, Claude Thornhill, and Stan Kenton, among others, opened the Tumwater Conservatory of Music. Before that he was playing around town at venues like the old Governor House on Capitol Way. He was joined by, among others, Jack Perciful, a master pianist who had played with Harry James for 18 years, and, occasionally, by the redoubtable, iconic Ernestine Anderson. Jan Stentz (vocals) and her husband Chuck (tenor sax) performed regularly with Barney McClure at the piano. Barney wrote arrangements for them. The Stentz’ owned Yenny’s, an Olympia music store, during this period.
From the late 1970s through the 1980s Olympia continued to be a hot venue for jazz and often featured musicians like Bert Wilson and Barbara Donald*, called, “one of the most original trumpet voices of her generation…” She followed Bert to Olympia. Her group Unity recorded one or two albums in the early 1980s. Bert Wilson followed friends from Berkeley to Olympia in 1980. Bert played with Smiley Winters and Sonny Simmons, and saxophonist Jim Pepper. Bert still performs and records regularly. Joe Baque, a seasoned studio pianist who played with Lena Horne, Stan Getz, and Louis Armstrong, moved to Olympia and became a beloved fixture. According to his published bio, it was love not musician pals that brought him to Olympia in 1983. Not only is Baque simply terrific as a soloist, he is generous to other musicians with his time, advice, and production savvy. He is a sought after accompanist and his name alone will draw a crowd and introduce a fledgling vocalist with all the bells and whistles Joe can muster…and those are aplenty. In these past few years, Jessica Williams, the brilliant jazz pianist and composer, moved to the area and appeared periodically at venues like The Art House. Jessica, who played with Stan Getz, Tony Williams, and Eddie Harris among other greats, received a Guggenheim in the field of composition and has been praised by people like Dave Brubeck. She has a healthy following and a resume that reads like a who’s who in jazz.
Must not forget the considerable Latin thread that has wound its way into the fabric that is Oly music. We locals celebrated Obrador appearances from 1976 through 2006. The group included Steve Bentley (drums), Steve Luceno (bass and guitar), and Tom Russell (primarily known for his hot woodwinds). In addition to club and festival appearances, Obrador, in its early days, played benefits for Greenpeace and the Crabshell Alliance among other progressive organizations. As an original member explains, “Obrador in Spanish means worker or workshop and obra can mean a work, construction, or musical composition. It was exactly what we were all about. A labor of love so to speak.”[i]
Ocho Pies, known for Afro-Cuban rhythms, came together in 1994 and featured Connie Bunyer on percussion (also of Obrador), Paul Hjelm on guitar and where needed, Luceno, and Michael Olson. Typical of Olympia based groups, Ocho Pies members engage in social action projects, specifically the Obrador Guanabacoa Project, founded by Obrador with La Escuela de Guiermo Tomas in Cuba. They called it quits after 18 years in September of 2012.
There are so many other groups and individuals it is impossible to name them in this brief review. But the participatory ensembles must be mentioned because they may be, in the end, the heart of it all. The Citizen’s Band first played at Evergreen State College on Earth Day. Harry Levine is credited for being the first mover of the group. He moved to Olympia in 1983 with the hope of starting a radical arts collective. There are currently four long timers on board (according to their web site). The band is unapologetically leftist, critical and anti-capitalist. The indefatigable Grace Cox, an original and long-term member of the Olympia Food Coop Collective, plays bass for the group. She wrote the lyrics to “Doin It,” one refrain of which includes this quintessential Olympian analysis of the world’s problems:
“So I said to myself, Self what is the matter? What’s keeping all these people from doing what they’d rather, It’s the chase for the dollar, the drive for success That’s keeping folks content with such unhappiness.”
Artesian Rumble Arkestra, whose members play for progressive fundraisers, welcome all comers and stand out on the corner of Percival Landing and 4th Avenue every Friday afternoon, rain and snow be damned. This is a group in the tradition of Honk! and street band culture. The philosophy of Honk! has been promulgated by ethnomusicologist Charlie Keil (Born to Groove) and spread by his students far and wide.[ii] Members blow their horns and beat their drums and generally play music that is of and for “the people.” Honk! enthusiasts aspire to overcome the “arbitrary social boundary” between performer and audience, a kind of “Dancing in the Streets”[iii] while blasting through the “fourth wall.”
Activist, pianist, and trombonist (her Artesian persona) Becky Liebman seems to have been critical in bringing this perspective on music and action to Olympia. She was involved in the first days of Samba OlyWa, a dynamic organized that evolved and is evolving still from its appearance at the first Procession of the Species in 1984. Essentially democratic at its core, it is open to anyone who comes out to practices either to play percussion or dance. Becky, aside from her membership in Arkestra, has been a key member of the band Bevy. Indeed Becky’s spirit and philanthropic commitment to social justice has been critical to the development of a trademark music that helps define Olympia. Nonprofessional, participatory expression of pure joy through music and movement, characterizes this brand.
Bevy’s members were either mentored by or regularly play with people already mentioned. Nancy Curtis for example, is Bert Wilson’s partner and though primarily a jazz musician, she can play just about anything and thrills audiences with her polish and virtuosity. Lisa Seifert not only plays clarinet with Bevy but hosts choro parties that draw folks from across the Oly music scene.
Not to say that The Evergreen State College didn’t in someway put its own musical stamp on the community. Arguably, its contribution to the Olympia scene came by way of providing a critical, progressive ambiance for composers and musicians, access to studios and technology (for enrolled students), and a general support for a local paradigm shift that supported and supports creativity and progressive values. Still, there were specific people and events associated with the college that surely had an influence on local music. One early faculty member was the charismatic Dumisani Maraire from Zimbabwe. His experience at the college perhaps exemplifies the clash between classical academic standards and perceptions of “professionalism” vs. the world music/participatory sensibility he brought to students. Specifically, a colleague of his, though ostensibly an expert on Indian tabla drumming (but not himself a drummer) continually complained about the “noise” Dumi made in his classes. Since those days, the colleague’s work has been roundly criticized in print by other professionals for its lack of accuracy and misreadings of the Indian tabla tradition. The inaccuracies are at least partly, the critic claims, because the man did not himself play. I’d like to say that such tight-assed approaches to music and performance didn’t exist at all in the early days of Evergreen. What I can assert is that it was, arguably, the college’s progressive ideology as a whole and its ability to draw innovative, broadminded students to the area and not individual faculty (with some exceptions) or programs, that contributed to the making of the Olympia Phenomenon.
Dumi performed with and taught mbira and marimba and often said, “if you can talk you can sing, if you can walk you can dance.” His students fanned out across North America and formed marimba groups wherever they landed. And his son (Tendai Maraire of Shabazz Palaces Hip Hop collective in Seattle)and other Maraire (spell check) kin carry on and honor his legacy with various projects.
Evergreen also brought the fabulous Odetta to Olympia as an artist in residence in 1982. Odetta, like so many contemporary, eminent roots musicians, did not grow up with folk music. She learned, listened, and even visited the Library of Congress’s Archive of American Folk Song to grow her repertoire. The Archive was founded in 1928 and was consolidated with the Archive of Folklife Center and renamed the Archive of Folk Culture in 1978. The Traditional Music and Spoken Word Catalog contains “approximately 34,000 ethnographic sound recordings,” made between 1933-1950, including all of Alan Lomax’ work.[iv]It is a abiding source of information and inspiration for serious roots musicians and students of Americana.
Alternative music was given a mighty boost in Olympia with the Yo Yo A Go Go festival in July of 1994. Pat Maley who fronted a local small independent label called Yo Yo Recordings organized the event. The multi-day happening featured several dozen bands and drew people from all over the U.S.
The bicoastal Riot grrrl movement, often referred to as a feminist punk movement, was strong in Olympia beginning in the 1990s. Precursors locally were women’s bands such as Noh Special Effects (known for “skank, slam, and wiggle according to one of their gig posters) including performance artists such as Chelsea Bonacello, appeared occasionally in the late 1970s and early 1980s at the Rainbow and Carolyn LaFond’s coffee shop, the Intermezzo. The Intermezzo opened in 1978 and has been touted to have housed the “first espresso machine installed between Portland and Seattle.” The Intermezzo also provided a gathering place for the women’s community, including activists, writers, and musicians.
A Wikipedia article notes that in the early 1990s, “Olympia…area had a sophisticated do it yourself infrastructure.” Hence, young women created, “punk-rock and fanzines and form (ed) garage bands.” Allison Wolfe, who grew up in Olympia, is quoted as saying of Olympia in the early 1990s, “It was a really hippie town, and we were getting really politicized…so we kinda started creating.” Bratmobile was born. And so many others. This music and these musicians were probably among the most political, in your face folks to rise from the yeasty mix I call the Olympia Phenomenon. The members of this group were smart, loud, dedicated and influential in many ways. One woman told me not long ago, “Hearing the Riot grrls on stage was the first time I knew I could say things out loud, things that I’d always wanted to say.”
The first Ladyfest was organized and hosted in Olympia in 2000. People credited with making it all happen are Sarah Dougher, Sleater-Kinney (the band), and Teresa Carmondy.
For more on alternative bands and the general scene in Olympia in 2000, you can’t do better than to read Ben Nugent’s Time Magazine article, “Olympia Ladystyle.” It was because of his piece that Olympian began to agree that they lived in “the hippest town in the west.” That aside, Nugent tapped a truth about Olympia and the Phenomenon when he elicited the punkers’ acknowledgement of the fundamental mutual influence and support musicians could get in this small town. “Someone comes up with the seed of an idea,” Mirah Yom Tov Zeitlyn is quoted as saying, “…and the rest of us are poised for action.” This describes, in brief, is the synergistic nature of this place. 
A little more on Alice Stuart. Alice was born in Chelan, Washington, then got her start in the early 1960s in Seattle. She was on the bill at the Berkeley Folk Festival in 1964 and now, after years and years of success and touring with the greats (including Mississippi John Hurt and Van Morrison and was a member of The Mothers of Invention with Frank Zappa) lives in Olympia. She has gigs all over but can, fortunately for us, still be heard locally and is frequently at the Royal Lounge on Capital these days.
To Have or To Be: Emergence and The Mystery of a Musical Community
Maybe it really is the water as Olympia’s eponymous beer claimed was what gave it a unique, indefinable quality. It could be. After all, the discovery of Lithia springs arguably made Ashland what it is today. All those progressive Southern Oregon folk sipping from the depths and realizing that they could speak Shakespearian English and, collectively, had the makings of a great little resort town!
In Olympia, people still happily trek to the artesian spring at 4th and Jefferson to fill vast jugs for their weekly supply. According to one blogger, a 1940s survey identified 96 active artesian wells and springs in the general area of the town. Olympia beer arguably put Olympia on the map but being known as “the hippest town in the west” has kept it there and helped its resident hip-types develop a kind of self-consciousness about its unique status.
But beyond hip, it is has more happening music per capita than most other U.S. burgs. Maybe its just something about the magnetic position of Olympia on the earth that causes everyone here to pick up an instrument and want to play it with somebody else. I really don’t know. It just seems true. One of the first things you learn about someone at a party is that they have a guitar or a fiddle or sing. Next thing you know, you are making plans to play together or listen to each other.
As I posited above, Zeitlyn and Nugent were on to something when they talked about the merits of a small town for musicians. The zeitgeist that has characterized Olympia of the past forty years required a mixture of ingredients and cultural inventions to come evolve. We know that “synergy” is defined as the coming together of two or more things that then produce something bigger, greater, and different than the mere sum of parts. Anthropologist Ruth Benedict took this idea further when applying it to culture. “From all comparative material the conclusion emerges that societies where non-aggression is conspicuous have social orders in which the individual by the same act and at the same time serves his own advantage and that of the group … not because people are unselfish and put social obligations above personal desires, but when social arrangements make these identical”. Abraham Maslow the psychologist who coined the term self-actualization went further after reading (and editing for publication) Benedict’s lecture notes on the topic of synergy. He said, in discussing the subjects of his own studies of self actualized people that, “the …opposition between heart and head…was seen to disappear where they became synergic rather than antagonistic…the dichotomy between selfishness and unselfishness disappears…Our subjects are simultaneously very spiritual and very pagan and sensual. Duty cannot be contrasted with pleasure nor work with play when duty is pleasure….” What better way to describe the multifarious, overlapping, celebratory, cooperative pools of musical fools in Olympia over the last forty years or so.
.Non-aggression: these folks tend to be anti violence anti war pro peace in how they behave personally and in what activities they tend to support by their actions which include fundraiser for a range of the disaster stricken and less fortunate both in Olympia and abroad.
.Social arrangements make self-interest and duty identical!: Indeed. Individuals want to play and perform. Groups make this possible and that the group has other goals beyond pure performance make duty part of the package. Duty is, indeed, pleasurable and rewarding in so many ways.
.And you can’t beat Samba OlyWa, for example, for combining the pagan and the sensual. Procession of the Species and Luminary Procession and Ball is the ritualized, climacteric point in each year when everybody can pull out the stops and let’er rip in full costume and with the fervor of animals in rut. Samba OlyWa is a core participant in Procession. It became clear a few years ago that Olympia people saw the Procession as theirs, not the property of one of its founders and director who tried to reel in and punish some participants whose costumes, he believed, did not properly manifest the spirit of the Procession. Outcry. The 2013 web page for the Procession states simply that it was created by the community for the community. And nobody better mess with that ideology.
So Olympia provides a context for synergetic things to happen and for people to find each other and play together. But what are the ingredients that helped this happen?
Because I don’t know what Olympia was like in the 1960s and 1950s, I’ll talk about the early 1970s. That’s when the paradigms were shifting. It was a period of anti-war protests, it was a period of growing feminism and gay activism, and it was a period of experimentation with alternative cultures. It was all of this and much more. Coincidentally, The Evergreen State College opened its doors in Olympia and drew people to it who were engaged in all of the above. They started businesses, coops, and musical groups. They started producing, not just consuming. The definition of family and community was massaged into something that included networks of friends with like values and goals and teamwork. People out of the early 70s started organizing workshops like the popular Puget Sound Guitar Workshop (1974) where musicians and wannabes met, bonded, and came home with a will to keep playing together. People found each other, invited each other, built on each others’ expertise and ideas, and voila.
Put this together with the simple fact that Olympia’s downtown core, with its principle venues, is small. You can walk the stretch of Capitol Way between the capitol grounds and the public market within about 15 minutes. Along the walk, you pass a small but accommodating Sylvester Park with a beautiful gazebo…the park and gazebo just perfect for rallies and small outdoor concerts and all kinds of festivities. In the market itself is a covered stage for performance. Theatre spaces in the core that were on their last legs were long ago usurped for community based productions, particularly the Olympia Film Society’s Capitol Theatre which hosts music groups galore as well as music festivals. Combine this with the availability of relatively inexpensive housing on both the east and west sides of Olympia, commodious thirties style houses. These were quickly occupied by students looking for shared housing possibilities after Evergreen Sate College came to town. The houses were and are amenable, some of the larger ones, for the use of politically based communal houses as well as for musical rehearsals and the development of pickup, experimental bands.
Think emergence theory. No one thing or person or event explains the Olympia music scene and its propensity to attract and support great musicians. As in philosophy, the very complex set of interacting groups and people in Olympia is what it is because of many individual events and actions over the years. It is what political philosophers might call “made order” as opposed to a conscious creation. It is real, it is palpable, and we all benefit by what we have collectively created here.
One last theoretical notion and then I promise to stop. Eric Fromm, a social psychologist, wrote a great book called To Have or To Be. Because so much of Olympia’s music scene is imbued with or generates from the early 1970s paradigm shift in values (fed by the people who gravitated here during this period, in some cases drawn by innovative curricula and structure of The Evergreen State College), Fromm’s distinction between having and being makes sense in understanding the community. Having characterizes a society or culture which is driven by materialism, by possessions, and by acquisition. Selfishness and greed. Being characterizes active culture in which experience, relationship, sharing, giving, and sacrifice. Fromm suggests that the culture in which we live, including the socioeconomic structure of our society, fosters one of these two potentials. Though we may live in nation that makes the desire to have a strong pull, it is true that many Olympians have found ways to opt for being.
It is true that Citizen’s band members and most of the musicians and others who are true Believers/Be-livers probably don’t have health insurance or much of anything else. They barter, tend to live simply, work day jobs so they can make music at night, give lessons to newbie’s and wannabes to supplement the little that comes in from gigs, and generally walk lightly on the planet. The professionals haven’t got much either. And they really do have to keep working many more years than those who have regular jobs with “benefits.” Jessica Williams recently put out a plea for help to cover a year of not playing because of spinal surgery. That’s the position people who give us years and years of pleasure end up in given our current system of health care and support for the arts. But it is also, for some, that state of relatively happy deprivation and simple, musical living that makes Olympia what it is. And you thought it was just another state capital.
**Both Bert and Barbara have passed on since this article was written. Bert died early June 2013 at age 73. Barbara died March 23, 2013 in Olympia. She was 70.
 Also see the 2012 Love Rock Revolution: K Records and the Rise of Independent Music by Mark Baumgart
 http://www.worldtrans.org/essay/synergy.html Benedict and Maslow are quoted in Flemming Funch’s essay from 1994 and Maps of the Mind by Charles Hampden-Turner. Benedict’s lecture notes on synergy were published posthumously in the American Anthropologist New Series, Vol. 72, No. 2 (April, 1970). Pp. 320-333. The article is called Synergy: Some notes of Ruth Benedict, by Abraham H. Maslow and John J. Honigman
[i] MAXSAX post on http://forum.saxontheweb.net/showthread.php?113311-The-Forgotten-American-Manufacturer/page3
[ii] see http://www.harmonicdissidents.org/archive/in-issue-2/what-is-a-honk-band/
[iii] Dancing in the Streets: A History of Collective Joy by Barbara Ehrenreich